top of page
Writer's pictureElliot Fisher

The Truth About Gyms, Weight Loss, and Real Fitness Success


Dumbbell on analog gym bodyweight scales
Losing weight in the gym may not be all that you think it is

It’s common for people to sign up for a gym membership with the goal of losing weight. Unfortunately, many don’t stick with it for long. As a gym owner and personal trainer, I’ve seen this cycle play out far too often. People expect the gym to deliver quick weight-loss results and grow disillusioned when the progress doesn’t match their expectations.


This isn’t to say weight loss in the gym is impossible, it absolutely works for some. But the reality is that the gym alone isn’t the most efficient or reliable way to shed body fat. The mismatch between expectations and outcomes often leads to people quitting before they see any meaningful benefits. To help you avoid the same pitfalls, I’ll explain why this happens and why focusing on building your body’s strength and fitness is the better reason to join a gym.


Why gyms alone aren't ideal for weight loss

Let’s address the main issue: burning calories through exercise is slow, and your body has mechanisms that reduce its effectiveness over time. You might burn 300 calories in a high-intensity session, but the body compensates by subconsciously reducing your activity later. You may fidget less, stand less, or even sleep deeper, which offsets the energy you burned. You can read more about energy regulation here and why 300 calories burned actually comes out as only 100.


The tools in the gym; weights, cardio machines, and classes aren’t specifically designed for rapid calorie burn. Yes, they burn calories, but they’re better suited for other benefits, like building strength, improving fitness, and enhancing movement patterns. If you focus solely on weight loss in the gym, you may become frustrated by how slowly progress occurs, even if you’re working hard.

There’s another factor at play: most calorie estimates provided by machines or fitness trackers are wildly inaccurate. These tools might tell you that you burned 500 calories, but the actual number could be much lower. This inaccuracy often leads people to overeat, believing they’ve burned more than they did.


You don’t buy a car just for the seat; you buy it for the independence and utility it provides. Similarly, you shouldn’t join a gym solely for its impact on weight loss. The real value lies in the strength, fitness, and confidence you gain along the way.

Moreover, many people unknowingly compensate for burned calories by rewarding themselves afterward. It could be as simple as indulging in a treat you "earned" after the workout, negating the progress entirely. A single biscuit or sugary drink can wipe out the calorie deficit from your session.


For example, You could burn the 180 kcal from high intensity exercise then 'reward' yourself with more rest later on. In that rest you burn (as example) 100 kcal less than if you had been doing something more active. Overall, you're then only 80 kcal expended more than normal...until you have that 1 chocolate hobnob biscuit coming it at 93 kcal as you "deserve it". Thus all your calories burned from exercise are completely gone! Don't worry, we will get onto how to lose weight a bit further down.


Weight loss begins in the kitchen

The most significant factor in weight loss is controlling your calorie intake. The kitchen, not the gym, is where the real work happens. If you’re overeating, no amount of exercise will make up for it. You could spend an hour sweating on a treadmill, but if your diet isn’t aligned with your goals, the scale won’t budge.


Weight loss requires creating a calorie deficit, which means consistently eating fewer calories than you burn. That’s much easier to control through diet than exercise. Making simple dietary change, like cutting back on sugary drinks, reducing portion sizes, or choosing nutrient-dense foods, has a far greater impact than an hour in the gym.


As an example a Venti Mocha from Starbucks comes in at 450 kcal whereas a Tall Mocha without the cream is 160 kcal less and takes no extra effort to order plus saves a few pennies. From our Personal Training clients we've found just removing 100 kcal a day is enough to lose weight at a healthy rate of about a pound a week (0.5 kg).

The difference bewteen starbucks coffee portion sizes
Changing portion sizes can have a great effect on fat loss

It’s also more sustainable. Adjusting your eating habits integrates into your daily life, whereas relying solely on the gym requires carving out dedicated time and energy. For long-term success, focus on building healthy eating habits first and treat the gym as a complement to your overall routine.


The actual purpose of the gym

While the gym isn’t the best tool for weight loss, it’s invaluable for other reasons. The gym is where you build a stronger, more capable body that supports your overall well-being. Strength training, in particular, offers benefits that extend far beyond aesthetics or calorie burn.


When you lift weights, you’re not just working your muscle, you’re strengthening your bones, improving joint health, and enhancing your nervous system. These changes make you more resilient and reduce your risk of injury. They also prepare you for the challenges of daily life, whether it’s carrying groceries, climbing stairs, or keeping up with your kids.

Distracted boyfriend gym goals girlfriend
The gym offers so many outstanding benefits bbeyond weight management

The gym can also boosts your cardiovascular fitness, which improves heart health and lung capacity. This doesn’t just make physical tasks easier; it enhances your overall energy levels and mental clarity. A fit body supports a fit mind, helping you stay sharp and focused throughout the day.


Having a strong and fit body gives you independence now and into later life. Being fit enough to be in control of your body gives you the freedom to enjoy life. For example:

  • You can trek on holiday without fear of whether you can make the trip.

  • You can go christmas shopping without being weighed down.

  • Being strong from using the gym makes you more employable being able to take on more physically demanding jobs or have the energy at the end of the day to keep doing tasks.

  • Keeping healthy shows traits of commitment and hard work most employers are looking for in a promotion.


Then add in the benefits of a strong physique when you need it in a pinch:

  • Recovery rates from surgery are faster in people with more muscle mass.

  • Injury rates are reduced when you have more strength to catch a fall.

  • Cancer risks are reduced, heart condition risk is reduced, diabetes is easier to manage if it manifests at all.

  • Cognitive function is better in those that exercise; alzheimers and parkinsons is less prevalent in physically active individuals.

  • Pregnancy is easier to manage if your back and legs are already stronger.

  • Menopause doesn't hit as hard if your hormones are being regulated from lifting heaving stuff.

  • Bones are stronger, organs filter better, digestion is boosted.

  • Your nervous system is more attuned to its surroundings giving you better coordination and motor control.


Should you really give up on the gym because the scales didn't move as much as you'd like after a week and miss out on all the other huge advantages consistent gym use brings with time?


The indirect benefits on weight loss from the gym

Exercise contributes to weight loss in indirect but meaningful ways. Regular gym sessions improve your mood, reduce stress, and help regulate your appetite. When you feel good mentally and physically, you’re more likely to make healthier choices outside the gym.


The discipline you develop through consistent workouts often carries over into other areas of life. It takes effort to stick with a training program, and that same effort can help you resist the temptation of unhealthy foods or stay committed to your weight-loss plan.


Exercise also improves your sleep quality, which plays a critical role in weight management. When you’re well-rested, your body regulates hunger hormones more effectively, reducing cravings and preventing overeating.


Modern media distorts weight loss expectations

Car advertising is misleading
Take away the background, the nomad travel culture and retro accessories. It's just an old car.

Modern media often portrays weight loss like a car commercial, showing a sleek, idealized version of reality. Just as car ads feature vehicles gliding effortlessly through scenic roads, weight-loss media paints a picture of quick, dramatic transformations. But in real life, the car is more likely a tool for the daily grind; commuting, school runs, and grocery trips. Similarly, real weight loss is far more mundane than the flashy promises of some workout videos, diet plans, and fitness trainers.


The truth is less glamorous. Weight loss is the result of countless choices made consistently over time: great workouts, boring ones, occasional indulgences, and steady, often invisible progress. It takes months, not days, and comes with plenty of ups and downs. The media’s focus on quick fixes and instant gratification leaves many disillusioned when reality doesn’t match the fantasy.


You can shield yourself from these illusions by looking out for the tell-tale signs. Media campaigns thrive on exaggeration. To avoid falling victim to unrealistic promises, watch for these red flags:

  • Excessive Buzzwords: Words like "shred," "torch," and "melt" sound powerful but rarely reflect realistic outcomes.

  • Lack of Specifics: If an ad doesn’t include measurable details like how much weight you can expect to lose or over what timeframe, it’s likely overselling.


Consider the hype around High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT). It was marketed with the “afterburn effect,” claiming that you’d continue burning calories long after the workout ended, though not stating how many this could be. Many assumed this meant hundreds of extra calories burned. The reality? You might burn an additional 60 calories over 24 hours; not even enough for a snack. While HIIT is effective for fitness, its marketed benefits were exaggerated to draw attention.


Buzzwords like “shred” and vague timelines play on our hopes for quick, dramatic results. When specifics are left out, people assume progress will happen faster than is realistic. This mismatch between expectations and reality often leads to disappointment.


Weight loss is the result of countless choices made consistently over time: great workouts, boring ones, occasional indulgences, and steady, often invisible progress

The bigger picture

Think of the gym as a tool in your weight-loss journey, not the whole solution. Joining a gym can enhance your physical capabilities and give you the structure and motivation to stay on track. But if you’re not addressing your nutrition, your results will be limited.


Compare it to buying a car. You don’t buy a car just for the seat, you buy it for the independence and utility it provides. Similarly, you shouldn’t join a gym solely for its impact on weight loss. The real value lies in the strength, fitness, and confidence you gain along the way.


By focusing on building a stronger body, you’ll unlock benefits that go far beyond a smaller number on the scale. You’ll improve your quality of life, reduce your risk of disease, and gain the freedom to enjoy activities without physical limitations.

Happy woman on gym mat
The gym is one piece of the puzzle. Once that sinks in, your time wil be more rewarding.

How to lose weight alongside the gym

If you want to lose weight and improve your fitness, start by setting realistic goals. Understand that progress takes time, think in months, not weeks. Instead of chasing 30-day quick fixes, commit to sustainable changes that you can maintain for the long term and understand how nutrition interacts with you with the Nutrition Hierarchy Guide.


Strength training should be a cornerstone of your routine, especially if you want to “tone.” Building muscle not only improves your appearance but also boosts your metabolism, helping you burn more calories at rest. An extra half a kilo of muscle mass burns about 6 kcal extra per day. Combine this with tracking your calorie intake, which is one of the most effective tools for weight management and you'd be well on your way.


Finally, don’t overlook the importance of patience and consistency. Weight loss is a gradual process, and the results you want won’t happen overnight. Stay focused on your goals, and remember that every small step you take brings you closer to success. Because the media was slated above for specificity. A healthy rate of loss is around 0.5 - 1.0 kg per week for hormone and habit stability. That equates, generally, to an inch off the waist every 3 weeks or so and down a jean or dress size every 6 weeks.


Losing weight in the gym is an option and works however is not the primary method and should only be treated as a bonus. Addressing your nutrition should be the main focus for weight loss in these 4 steps:


  1. Firstly stop looking for that miracle diet! Stop looking for the magic shortcut. The magic you're looking for is the discipline and hard work you're avoiding.


  2. Second. Set a goal. Get into the nitty gritty of what success realistically looks like for you and be patient. If all things are going well, you'd be looking to lose half a stone every 6 weeks. It'll be 12 weeks before your clothes start to fit differently and reliably be a dress/jean size down.


  3. Third. Get a grip...of some weights. Most people aren't looking for sheer weight loss alone. Many want to "tone" which usually involves muscle mass which best comes from heavy resistance training. Endless time on the cardio machines will not give you the elusive "tone" you're chasing. It's not actually that elusive, you're just looking for fish in the clouds.


  4. Fourth and most important. Track your calories. If you have the energy and time to send a text message, you have the time to track your calories. It will take a week or two to learn to do it but the awareness you gain will last you a lifetime. The truth of energy balance is laid out plain to see and unlike most fad diets does not cost anything. There's no hidden agenda or sales, no branded shakes or vitamins you have to buy from a certain company that, unsurprisingly, claims they are the best. Tracking calories is all about you, taking responsibility for what goes down your throat hole.


Bonus tip: Just stop alcohol. It has absolutely zero benefits and too many problems. Even cake can be used as fuel for the brain.


You may also like to read


Closing thoughts

As a gym owner, I want to see my members succeed, not just in reaching their fitness goals, but in adopting habits that improve their overall well-being. Weight loss may be part of your journey, but it shouldn’t be your only reason for joining a gym.


Focus on building a stronger, fitter body, and let the other benefits: better health, improved mood, and increased confidence, be your motivation. The gym is a powerful tool, but it works best when paired with a balanced diet and an active lifestyle.


Use the gym for what it’s designed to do: make you stronger, fitter, and more capable. Let your kitchen handle the weight loss, and together, they’ll help you become the best version of yourself.

 
Strength - Resilience - Consistency
 


13 views0 comments

Comments


Thanks for subscribing!

bottom of page